Thomas Risk Solutions · Insurance, in plain English

Medicare Enrollment Mistakes to Avoid

Watercolor illustration of a man in his sixties at a sunlit kitchen table, hand to his forehead in surprise as he reads a letter, as if he has just realized a costly Medicare enrollment mistake

The Medicare enrollment mistakes worth avoiding come down to timing and checking: missing your Initial Enrollment Period, delaying Part B or drug coverage on coverage that doesn’t count, letting the one-time Medigap Open Enrollment Period pass, choosing a plan without checking your doctors and drugs, and leaving it on autopilot without reading its yearly notice. Some, like the Part B and Part D late enrollment penalties, can last as long as you have that coverage.

Sourced from Medicare.gov’s pages on when coverage starts, late enrollment penalties and when to buy Medigap, and the Medicare & You handbook (CMS Pub. No. 10050).

Key takeaways
  • At 65, enrollment is generally automatic only if you're getting Social Security or Railroad Retirement Board benefits at least four months before your birthday. Otherwise, you have to sign up.
  • Only group coverage based on current employment generally lets you delay Part B without a penalty. COBRA and retiree coverage don't count.
  • The 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period happens once. It doesn't come back each fall.
  • Before you pick a plan, and again each fall, check your own doctors and prescriptions against it.

1. Assuming you’ll be signed up automatically

If you’re already getting Social Security or Railroad Retirement Board benefits at least four months before you turn 65, you’ll generally be enrolled in Part A and Part B automatically. If you aren’t, because you’re still working or waiting to claim Social Security, nothing happens until you apply. You sign up through Social Security, or through the Railroad Retirement Board if your benefits come through them.

Your Initial Enrollment Period is seven months long: the three months before the month you turn 65, that month, and the three months after.

3 months before Month you turn 65 + 3 after −3 −2 −1 65 +1 +2 +3 Part B generally starts the month you turn 65 Part B generally starts the month after you sign up The box marked 65 is the month you turn 65
Your seven-month Initial Enrollment Period. Signing up earlier in the window helps coverage begin when you expect. If your birthday falls on the 1st of a month, your dates shift a month earlier; Social Security can confirm yours.

2. Missing that window with nothing to fall back on

If the Initial Enrollment Period passes and you don’t qualify for a Special Enrollment Period, the next chance to sign up for Part B is the General Enrollment Period, January 1 through March 31 each year, with coverage starting the month after you sign up. That gap can leave you without Part B for months, and a late enrollment penalty may apply on top: your Part B premium can go up 10% for each full 12-month period you could have had Part B and didn’t, generally for as long as you have Part B. I explain how both penalties are figured in Medicare’s late enrollment penalties.

3. Delaying Part B on coverage that doesn’t qualify

You may be able to delay Part B without a penalty if you have group health coverage based on current employment, your own or your spouse’s. COBRA and retiree coverage are not current employment. When the job or the group coverage ends, whichever happens first, you generally have 8 months to sign up for Part B, and electing COBRA doesn’t extend that clock. The rules also look at your coverage history since you first became eligible, so ask Social Security to confirm you qualify before you delay.

Employer size matters too. If the employer has fewer than 20 employees, Medicare may pay first (multi-employer and union plans can follow their own rules), and delaying Part B could leave gaps in what gets paid. Confirm with the plan before you delay. And if you contribute to an HSA, enrolling in Medicare, even Part A alone, affects your ability to keep contributing; check the timing with a tax professional. My post on working past 65 walks through all of it.

Before you elect COBRA at 65: picture someone who retires at 66, keeps their old employer plan through COBRA, and plans to sign up for Part B "when COBRA runs out." By then, the 8-month window that started when their job ended may already be closed. If you're 65 or older and leaving a job, sort out Part B first, then decide about COBRA.

4. Going without creditable drug coverage

Part D is a separate decision with a separate penalty. After your Initial Enrollment Period, a Part D late enrollment penalty can apply if you go 63 or more days in a row without Part D or other creditable drug coverage, meaning drug coverage expected to pay, on average, at least as much as Medicare’s. Employer and union plans must tell you in writing whether their drug coverage is creditable. Keep those notices; they’re your proof later.

5. Assuming you can buy Medigap any time

The 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period starts the first month you’re 65 or older and have Part B. Medicare.gov calls it the best time to buy a policy. It happens once and doesn’t repeat each fall. Outside it, unless a guaranteed issue right applies, there’s no federal guarantee an insurer will sell you a policy, and your health history can affect whether you’re accepted and what you pay. SHIIP can tell you whether North Carolina adds any protections for your situation. Because the window is tied to Part B, when you start Part B also decides when your Medigap window opens.

The same caution applies later. Choosing Medicare Advantage now and planning to “switch back” to Original Medicare with a Medigap policy later needs a separate check: outside your Medigap Open Enrollment Period, medical underwriting can apply unless a guaranteed issue right protects you. SHIIP can confirm your rights before you make the change. I cover the details in switching Medigap plans, and if the names are getting tangled, Medicare Supplement vs. supplemental insurance sorts out two products that sound alike.

6. Picking a plan without checking your doctors and drugs

If you’re choosing a Medicare Advantage plan, confirm with the plan and your doctors’ offices that your doctors and hospitals take it. For drug coverage, check each prescription against the plan’s drug list (formulary), check your pharmacy, and ask about any approval requirements. The Medicare Plan Finder on Medicare.gov is a starting point. In Charlotte, part of that check is knowing which hospital system your doctors belong to; I wrote about that in Atrium or Novant.

7. Letting your plan renew without reading the yearly notice

You should receive your plan’s Annual Notice of Change by September 30. If it hasn’t arrived, contact the plan. It lays out what changes January 1, which can include costs, the drug list and the network. If you do nothing, your coverage generally continues with those changes. The Annual Enrollment Period (AEP), October 15 through December 7, is the yearly window to act on what you read. My posts on what to review before AEP closes and re-checking Part D every fall cover what to look for.

8. Mixing up the enrollment windows

Your Medicare & You handbook calls October 15 – December 7 the Open Enrollment Period; I call it the Annual Enrollment Period (AEP), because “open enrollment” also names two other windows below. AEP is for changing plans, not for first signing up for Part A or Part B.

Window When What it’s for
Initial Enrollment Period 7 months around the month you turn 65 Signing up for Part A and Part B, and joining a plan
General Enrollment Period January 1 – March 31 Signing up for Part B if you missed your window; a penalty may apply
Part B Special Enrollment Period While you’re still covered through current work, or up to 8 months after the job or that coverage ends, whichever comes first Signing up for Part B after delaying on qualifying work coverage; Social Security can confirm your dates
Medigap Open Enrollment Period 6 months, starting the first month you’re 65+ and have Part B; one time only The time Medicare.gov calls best for buying a Medigap policy
Annual Enrollment Period (AEP) October 15 – December 7 Joining, switching or dropping Medicare Advantage and drug plans for January 1
Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period January 1 – March 31 (new enrollees may have a separate window) People already in Medicare Advantage can make one change

If you joined Medicare Advantage when you first got Medicare, you may also be able to make one change in your first three months with Part A and Part B; Medicare.gov can confirm your dates. That January window allows a switch to another Medicare Advantage plan, with or without drug coverage, or a return to Original Medicare with a separate drug plan; it can’t be used to move from Original Medicare into Medicare Advantage. Special Enrollment Periods cover other situations, but timing, plan choices and proof requirements depend on the specific event, so check the rules before counting on one. If December 7 has already passed, what happens if you miss the Annual Enrollment Period walks through what’s still open.

Richard's tip: before any deadline-driven decision, write down three dates: when your Initial Enrollment Period ends, when your current work coverage ends, and when your Medigap Open Enrollment Period would start. Seeing them side by side is how you catch a gap while there's still time to close it.

Where to get help

North Carolina’s Seniors’ Health Insurance Information Program (SHIIP), part of the NC Department of Insurance, counsels people on Medicare enrollment at 855-408-1212. Social Security handles Part A and Part B enrollment and penalty questions.

If you’re approaching 65, my turning-65 checklist puts these steps in order. And if you’d like to walk through your own dates, you can see how I help with Medicare or book a time to talk. I work with multiple carriers and I’m glad to help.

Keep reading

Editorial illustration of a doctor's office building and two hospital campuses connected by paths across a light, airy cityscape
November 14, 2026

Seeing a Tryon Medical Doctor? What to Check in Your Medicare Advantage Network

Read the article →
Editorial illustration of a sunlit autumn main street with a corner pharmacy under a teal awning and a row of shopfronts, in soft navy and teal tones
November 11, 2026

What Is the Medicare Prescription Payment Plan?

Read the article →
Editorial illustration of two rocking chairs, one navy and one teal, side by side on a white front porch looking out on an autumn street lined with trees
November 6, 2026

Does Medicare Cover Your Spouse?

Read the article →
Questions about your own coverage?

I personally respond to every inquiry — no call centers, no pressure.

Book Your Call with Richard